Thursday, December 20, 2018

PTI files disqualification petition against Zardari for 'concealing' NY flat in nomination papers

PTI files disqualification petition against Zardari for 'concealing' NY flat in nomination papers

The Pakistan Teh­reek-i-Insaf (PTI) on Thursday filed associate application with the committee of Pakistan (ECP) in metropolis, seeking the disqualification of PPP co-chairperson Asif Ali Zardari for concealing his assets.

According to the appliance filed by PTI Sindh MPA Khurram Sherzaman with the Provincial Election Commissioner, Zardari had didn't declare an apartment he allegedly owns in Belaire Condominiums placed at 524 East 72nd Street, New York, USA in his nomination form for the 2018 general elections.

The PPP leader could be a member of the National Assem­bly from NA-213, shaheed Benazirabad, Sindh.

"Because of this act of his, Mr Asif Ali Zardari below the Constitution of the Muslim Republic of Pakistan and Rules of the commission of Pakistan, he as per past precedent, ought to be disqualified from holding public office below Article sixty two (1)(f), as in my opinion he ceases to be truthful and sagacious," says the appliance

Sherzaman in his letter said he was attaching documents of the property in question at the side of Zardari's form B, "which shows that he failed to declare this property".

"This serious violation of the law has to be examined by you since Mr Zardari could be a former President of Pakistan and co-chairs one of the most important political parties of this country," the appliance read.

Although Provincial Election Commissioner Muhammad Yousaf Khan Khattak reluctantly accepted the appliance filed by Sherzaman, he advised the PTI leader that any action on the petition would be taken by the ECP's Islamabad headquarters.

PPP to file disqualification petitions against PM, Vawda


Also on Thursday, the PPP filed applications within the ECP's capital of Pakistan office seeking details of assets of Prime Minister Imran Khan and Federal Minister for Water Resources Faisal ibn Abdel Aziz al-Saud Vawda.

After a PPP delegation met with the ECP secretary, party leader Farhatullah Babar told reporters they'd asked the commission to provide details of assets submitted by the premier for all elections he has oppose within the past.

"The money trail of Imran Khan's properties is suspect," Babar alleged, adding that his party can prove that Khan holds unacknowledged properties abroad.

The PPP has conjointly submitted applications in involved establishments to seek details of assets owned by the prime minister's sister, Aleema Khan, and of business interests of Jahangir Tareen, a senior PTI leader.

He aforesaid the PPP can file a disqualification reference against Khan and others "based on the proof we have a tendency to are gathering".

"We need everybody within the government and also the opposition to be control responsible under identical law," Babar said, adding that the PPP can face all cases against it through legal channels.

Wednesday, December 19, 2018

US envoy Zalmay Khalilzad discusses Afghan peace efforts with General Bajwa

US envoy Zalmay Khalilzad discusses Afghan peace efforts with General Bajwa


Zalmay Khalilzad, the US special envoy tasked with finding a negotiated finish to Afghanistan's 17-year recent war, on Wednesday referred to as on Army Chief General Qamar Javed Bajwa to debate regional security and also the first step in Afghanistan, the military’s advocator aforesaid.

According to a press release tweeted by the Inter-Services publicity chief, the “visiting very important person appreciated Pakistan’s efforts for [the] Afghan peace process”.


The army chief reiterated that “peace in Afghanistan is vital for Pakistan” and guaranteed that continuous efforts are going to be dispensed “for delivery peace and stability within the region”.

Earlier in the week, Washington had welcome Pakistan’s efforts to market peace talks between the Afghan government and also the Taleban.

The acknowledgement came on a daily basis once Prime Minister Imran Khan proclaimed that Pakistan had organized another round of talks between the United States and Taleban officers however he didn't say once and wherever.

“The US welcomes any actions by the Pakistani government to market bigger cooperation, together with fostering negotiations between the Taleban, the Afghan government, and different Afghans,” a United States of America embassy advocator was quoted as oral communication.

Prime Minister Khan had additionally highlighted Pakistan's "abiding interest" in achieving lasting peace and reconciliation in war-worn Afghanistan through a political settlement.

Monday, December 17, 2018

First Pak-aided US-Taliban talks command in UAE

First Pak-aided US-Taliban talks command in UAE

ISLAMABAD: united states diplomats and religious movement representatives met within the United Arab Emirates on Monday for talks expedited by Islamic Republic of Pakistan on finding a negotiated settlement of the war in Afghanistan.

The meeting in United Arab Emirates's capital was additionally attended by officers from Pakistan, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and also the UAE.

There were no statements from the collaborating parties at the top of the daylong meeting, though Pakistan’s ministry voice Dr Muhammad Faisal ibn Abdel Aziz al-Saud formally proclaimed the beginning of the talks through a tweet.

“Talks are being control in UAE,” Dr Faisal tweeted because the meeting within the UAE got beneath manner. He reiterated Pakistan’s commitment to peace and reconciliation in Afghanistan|Asian country|Asian nation} and expressed the hope that the engagement that began within the UAE would “end bloodshed in Afghanistan and produce peace to the region”.

He closely echoed a recent statement by the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Army’s governance during which it absolutely was aforementioned that the corps commanders meeting “hopes for achievement of in progress Afghan reconciliation method whereas supporting all stakeholders to bring Afghan war to a peaceful logical conclusion”.

It was the third meeting between the Taleban and U.S.A. officials since the appointment of Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad as U.S.A. special envoy for peace and reconciliation in Afghanistan. Their meeting last month continued for 3 days.

However, it absolutely was the primary meeting sponsored by capital of Pakistan and additionally the primary outside port that hosts Taliban’s political workplace and was the venue of the earlier 2 rounds. it's believed that the newest meeting was convened outside Qatar to underscore Pakistan’s role in transcription it and at identical time permitting participation of the UAE and Saudi Arabia, each of whom had last year cut diplomatic ties with port.

Ambassador Khalilzad led the U.S.A. facet, whereas Taleban were delineate at the talks by their ‘political negotiators’ from Qatar office.

Taliban representative Zabihullah Muslim had confirmed during a statement sent to VoA the participation of insurgents’ political negotiators within the meeting with american officers.

Pakistan had organized the meeting once receiving letter of invitation from America President Donald Trump for facilitate within the social process a two weeks past. Prime Minister Imran Khan had proclaimed the Pakistan-backed meeting within the UAE throughout his visit to metropolis last Friday.

The Afghan government wasn't depicted at Monday’s meeting as a result of religious movement have stood firmly on not lecture the Afghan government, whom they decision the puppet regime, and insisted on talking directly to the America.

The Afghan government, however, control consultations with the America, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and also the UAE each day before the talks with religious movement. Afghan National Security authority Hamdullah Mohib, UN agency took half within the quadrilateral meeting on Sunday, tweeted on Monday that “President Ashraf Ghani’s roadmap for peace given at Geneva and direct engagement of Afghan government with religious movement for intra-Afghan dialogue” were mentioned.

Kabul, despite not getting a seat at the talks, is seeing the method completely. The Washington Post quoted Shah of Iran Hussain Murtazawi, a interpreter for President Ghani, as having aforesaid that the US-Taliban meeting was being coordinated with the Afghan government. “The Afghan government supports any effort and action that paves the manner for an Afghan-led social process,” he said.

Sunday, December 16, 2018

Why did US blacklist Pakistan for religious freedom violations?

Why did US blacklist Pakistan for religious freedom violations?
 On December 11, U.S.A. Secretary of State mike Pompeo declared that the us had selected Pakistan as a “country of specific concern” for participating in or tolerating “systematic, ongoing, [and] egregious” religious freedom violations.

It’s the first time Washington has saddled Islamabad with this status; antecedently, Islamic Republic of Pakistan had been on a less serious watch list.

At first glance, the State Department’s call to blacklist Islamic Republic of Pakistan comes across as a deaf move.

Washington downgraded Pakistan’s spiritual freedom ranking at the terribly moment once capital of Pakistan has taken many unprecedented steps that counsel a want to help ease the plight of spiritual minorities.
Indeed, Pompeo’s announcement came simply weeks when Pakistan’s Supreme Court clean-handed Asia Bibi, a Christian girl on ward for blasphemy charges.

And it came simply days once officials proclaimed act of terrorism and infringement charges for Khadim Rizvi, {a religious|a spiritual|a non secular} conservativist WHO leads a bunch that rails against religious minorities and imply the execution of blasphemers.

So why designate Pakistan this year, and not last year or at the other previous time?

The answer is probably going unmoving in each U.S. policy goals and domestic political issues in America.

On one level, this was probably a calculated move owing to pressure techniques. The Trump White house is more and more bent distinguishing new measures to compel Pakistan|national capital} to require action against the Afghanistan-focused terrorist leaders it accuses Pakistan of harbouring.

These measures, in Washington’s read, should be relatiative however not excessively provocative — in order to preclude the chance of a piqued Pakistan movement down those ever-critical provide routes serving United States forces in Afghanistan.

In that regard, blacklisting Islamic Republic of Pakistan for non secular freedom violations fits the bill. It’s a reputational blow for Islamabad; it joins an unsavoury club that has Somalia and North Korea.

But otherwise, it’s not a really Draconian move. In fact, State Department officers, citing United States national interests, have declared they won’t slap sanctions on Pakistan, even if being blacklisted will invite such penalties.
In reality, it’s folly to assume this move will work as a pressure plan of action.

If Washington thinks shaming Islamic Republic of Pakistan for non secular freedom violations can compel it to magically engineer a dramatic shift in its long policies towards non-state militant actors, then it’s painfully mistaken.

The temporal arrangement is poor, too.

At a moment once the White House has ne'er been additional desirous to get Pakistan’s facilitate in transportation resolvable Taliban representatives to the negotiating table, penalising Pakistan can build the trust necessary for such cooperation even more durable to secure.

But there’s probably a additional parochial issue at play too.

Consider that 2 key senior United States officers concerned within the move to blacklist Islamic Republic of Pakistan — Pompeo and guided missile Brownback, the United States ambassador-at-large for international spiritual freedom — hail from the evangelical, Christian conservative wing of the party.

In that sense, each have reason to be significantly involved regarding the troubles of Christians in Pakistan.

While the 2 officers can have been inspired by the Supreme Court’s final decision of Asia Bibi, the actual fact that she still remains in Pakistan, along with her life at risk, is probably going of deep concern to them.

In a phone call with reporters regarding the m
Aove to blacklist Islamic Republic of Pakistan, Brownback same, “we still watch terribly fastidiously what's happening with Asia Bibi.”

He conjointly disclosed that the choice to blacklist Islamic Republic of Pakistan was due in great part to the country’s blasphemy laws. Christians are one among the most communities misused by the misuse of those laws.ccordingly, we are able to read Washington’s move partially as a real effort to carry the country a lot of in charge of its terribly real and extremely serious spiritual freedom violations — and significantly people who have an effect on Christians, a really personal matter for many key United States policymakers.

All this said, in spite of Washington’s motivations, the hypocrisy is crystal clear.

The Trump administration implements policies that expressly discriminate against Muslims (witness the travel ban), and it usually fails to without ambiguity condemn acts of violence against Hindus, Muslims and Jews in America.

And however this same administration continues to arrogate to itself the correct to penalize alternative countries for identical offenses.

Superpowerdom could confer sure privileges, however free passes shouldn’t be one among them. The united states warrants harsh criticism regarding the state of spiritual freedom on its own soil — which criticism ought to begin reception.

Indeed, once you call out countries abroad for identical issues that you just confront in your own curtilage, some critique will go a protracted manner — and ultimately facilitate bring a lot of believability to your cause.

India has spoken

India has spoken: The beginning of Modi’s end

On Tuesday, India created a replacement tryst with democracy by defeating the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) within the 3 region states. The margin of the Congress party’s conclusion could be narrow however the magnitude of the BJP defeat goes on the far side regional elections.



Never before has an electoral result given such relief to the lots WHO are living under encirclement ever since the BJP, under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, assumed office in 2014. Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh, that along conjure the Hindi region, weren’t the sole things at stake in these assembly elections; India’s soul was as much on the road.

With civil society being pushed to the margin, establishments of democracy under constant attack, minorities feeling fully humiliated and marginalised, liberals and seculars branded as anti-state and prominent public universities being became centres of Hindu majoritarianism, Modi’s government was creating India an unrecognisable place for its own voters.

The daring with that the BJP started treating its own folks was appalling to mention the least; manipulating media to propagate factory-made narratives, incursive people’s privacy and suppressing political dissent, Modi turned against the terribly those that brought him in power within the 1st place.

Hence, given this political scenario of the country, the assembly election results are a landmark outcome. The aura of strength that Modi had acquired over the years stands diminished. people have sent a message to the Indian prime minister that he needs to renounce his conceit and stop acting like God.

Never before in independent India’s history has a prime minister refused to speak to his own people and maintained silence on problems that seriously impact the country. Be it the killing of innocent Muslims for eating beef, the murder of a prominent journalist by a radical group or termination and different harsh economic measures, Modi selected to stay silent throughout.

A prime minister employed to further the agenda of development has instead been turning the nation into a laboratory job to his majoritarian project. Development has really become a set of this ideological agenda. rather than development, it's division and hostility that has been flourishing in India since 2014.

The recent verdict is therefore a warning signal and a robust disapproval of this complete of politics. The victory of the Congress party establishes the balance of power within the Indian polity. before the Tuesday elections, Congress had been suffering defeat after defeat since 2014. The weakening of Congress was emboldening right political parties and giving them political house that was too intrusive for a lay and multi-cultural republic.

The party leader Rahul Gandhi acquired an entire new aura when delivering 3 states to the Congress. Ridiculed and abused by the BJP for very long, the young Gandhi can directly challenge Modi within the General Elections to be command in 2019. This victory comes specifically a year when he assumed office as the party president.

The rejuvenation of the Congress party is a revival of hope in liberal and lay india. the decision may be a avowal of people’s faith in democracy and therefore the political middle path. people have spoken loud and clear that they need modification. it's currently the responsibility of lay political parties to come back together and build another strong enough to defeat the BJP government.

The BJP government nowadays incorporates a lot of money and takes its campaigning to an entire new level altogether. Winning an election against an opponent with strong company backing, very formidable media support and solid backing of state machinery won't be straightforward. we can only hope that a lay alliance under the leadership of the Congress are going to be a strong rival for the throne of new Delhi in 2019.

These election results additionally function a lesson for the media. it's vital that the media stops serving as a mouthpiece for Modi’s sectarian ideology and factious agenda. to this end, it's vital that the opposition’s voice be detected too. people have voted to say their own Asian nation. They don’t need revolution or radical change; they need their own democratic house.

Balochistan’s gas keeps the remainder of Islamic Republic of Pakistan heat

While Balochistan’s gas keeps the remainder of Islamic Republic of Pakistan heat, its own residents are physical change in silence.

On a cool and sunny November afternoon, Ahmad Habib Saturday behind his search, set in Quetta’s main Liaquat Bazar, amid one or two of different native search house owners. They Saturday together, enjoying the normal kahwa with Gur (jaggery), a drink designed to stay their bodies heat for long.

Unlike the past four years, this year’s winter is warm and appealing, principally because of associate abundance of sunny days. additional usually than not, period may be a time once the strength of the heat bit by bit weakens and funky, dry wind arrives for Associate in Nursing extended stay. These cool winds slowly whisper and signal the arrival of rain and snow on the mountains, and within the natural depression yet, creating this an excellent time to go to Quetta, significantly places like Hanna Lake, Wali Tungi and Bolan. As a bonus, Quetta conjointly gets its most vibrant sunsets within the winter.
Once the snow season kicks off, the Lak Pass and different extremely elevated routes across the mountains area unit closed because of serious precipitation. Here, the temperature in winter will create it unbearably cold, particularly because of gas shortages and power loadshedding which will last for 2 to 3 days.
       
         “The native traders too are finding it               exhausting to urge by. we've got                       foreign the newest brands of gas                     heaters from Karachi, Faisalabad,                  and  Gujranwala because of the                         expected cold and dry winter. These               new brands are equally equipped                  with thermostats that mechanically                bring to a halt the flow of gas a                       number of seconds when the flame is             destroyed, as a security measure.                      however it's unlikely for the sunny                 days to continue by the tip of                           November,” said Akram Mengal, as he          Saturday beside Habib.


Mengal owns a sequence of stores in numerous components of Quetta, being within the business of commercialism gas and electrical heaters since 2005.

“As a consequence of increased  gas costs, our businesses are affected and folks here are additional willing to shop for electrical heaters, hot fans, even ancient stoves, instead of gas heaters to stay their places heat and to organize food. However, the price of those gas heaters is much too high in comparison to costs over the past 2 to 3 years – about 600 to 1,000, counting on the scale and whole,” continuing Mengal.

Natural gas is one among the first sources of energy in most urban parts of Balochistan that is why gas heaters are thought-about integral, whereas rural areas are still lacking in higher facilities and are forced to have confidence ancient coal stoves, angethi (furnace) or wood fires. However, it's price mentioning that these ancient ways that of heating have wide acquire re-use in most components of Quetta and near  areas because of severe gas loadshedding.


The excitement of the folks of Quetta wasn't pervasive once the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) of the cabinet set to not subject customers to any gas loadshedding in Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) within the current winter season. The set up conferred by the petroleum division under the Ministry of Gas and petroleum secure to bring an amazing modification within the recent ways in which of gas offer this winter, and about a hundred and fifty to 200 mm cubic  feet (mmcf) of liquefied gas are going to be injected into the system to prevent gas loadshedding in Balochistan and K-P. it's been according that acute gas shortages within the extreme weather condition (minus six to ten degrees celsius) have resulted in casualties for native residents, significantly women and youngsters, over the past four years just about.

In September 2018, the computer code had raised gas costs starting from 100 percent for very cheap block customers to a surprising 143% for the best block domestic customers, whereas the rise ranged from 30 to 57 for business and industrial customers. this can for sure boil all the way down to a gradual rise within the costs of electricity, coal and alternative sources of energy. However, domestic gas customers have already been loaded down as a result of they need to pay a further Rs94 billion within the current year for gas utilities.

“It is kind of obvious that the emergency measure administrated by the new government led to additional issues than solutions. The ECC’s recent call to inject an oversized quantity of gas within the system will not be helpful for the center and lower middle categories, as a result of such a high quantity of gas is just too faraway from their approach,” said Mrs Shaista Khan, a senior teacher at the Islamia Girls’ highschool, Quetta.

As she rushed home with an oversized bundle of examination papers in her hand similarly as her 2 school-going daughters together with her, Mrs Khan continued ,

“This year we have a tendency to forced the college administration to rearrange the annual exams in period, as a result of last year the school’s management didn't give gas heaters within the lecture rooms and small children were forced to solve their annual papers as their bodies shivered within the severe period of time cold. it's not unlikely that a majority of native voters can go live with their relatives in Sindh and Punjab for this winter. i'm also aiming to leave along with my family in period of time and can be back in March next year, although people who don't have relatives in alternative cities can keep behind to face the cruel weather with no proper sources of energy and fuel, and have to be compelled to pay a serious a part of their monthly wage on gas and electricity bills. Either way, the provincial government won't listen to our long social and economic problems”.

Many provincial and federal officers argued within the past that this scenario in Balochistan ought to be treated as a clarion decision. in step with officers within the Oil and Gas regulatory agency (OGRA),

“We area unit operating laborious to confirm wonderful services area unit provided to gas shoppers everywhere the province, chiefly in Quetta. Moreover, so as to forestall gas thieving and meter tempering, gas meters over ten to 15-years-old area unit being replaced with a lot of advanced and speedy meters”.
On the contrary, an oversized range of native domestic gas shoppers have reportedly been accusatory the Sui Southern utility (SSGC) of tight Rs10,000 to Rs40,000 on false charges of meter meddling. although these questionable speedy gas meters were wide rejected by shoppers in Sindh and Punjab over serious technical faults, similar cases are according in varied components of Quetta, like Sariab Road, Satellite city and Pashtun Abad.

These stories don't seem to be distinctive. Their variants may be found in alternative districts and many villages across Balochistan, particularly within the Kalat, Zhob and Ziarat districts. Kalat is found 136 kilometers from Quetta and is understood as a historic town of Balochistan. The district has been witnessing gas loadshedding and low pressure for the past four years, whereas temperatures are falling from minus ten to minus fourteen degrees uranologist.

Meanwhile, Ziarat, the district once far-famed for its dense juniper forests, a tree that only grows an inch per year, has seen vanishing junipers because of the widespread cut-off caused by these shortages. Over the last 3 decades, the folks in Ziarat have mercilessly sliced these juniper trees to use them as fuel, because of the severe negligence of the SSGC. the attractive valley of Ziarat has no gas facility, and despite various guarantees within the past, no gas pipeline project is into consideration here up to now. The hills of Ziarat look virtually barren currently, and this reduced tree coverage has a perceptible impact on the dynamical climate, the annual quantity of downfall and also the scourge of deforestation within the entireness of Balochistan.

Despite the actual fact that Sui, Dera Bugti and different parts of Balochistan have the biggest quantity of gas reserves within the country, folks here are miserable, uncomfortable and neglected throughout the very cold winter. The less we tend to expect, the a lot of we tend to are neglected. Is there an end visible to our troubles?

Saturday, December 15, 2018

انصاف کے ڈبل معیار؟

الیما خانم جیل سے دوچار ہو گئے جبکہ میرم نواز کو جیل کے دوہری معیاروں کو بھیجا گیا تھا؟

وزیراعظم عمران خان کی بہن اللما خانم

 متحدہ عرب امارات میں اس کی جائیداد کو ظاہر نہیں کرنے کے لئے جرمانہ کیا گیا ہے، سپریم کورٹ (ایس سی) کے ساتھ اسے ٹھیک کرنے کے طور پر 29.4 ملین روپے جمع کرنے کا حکم دیا گیا ہے. تاہم، اس سے ان کی آمدنی کا ذریعہ ظاہر کرنے کے لئے نہیں کہا گیا تھا اور نہ ہی تحقیقاتی مشترکہ ٹیم (جئٹ) نے ان کی آمدنی کا ذریعہ تحقیق یا عدالت میں پیش کردہ پیسے کے راستے کی صداقت کے لئے حکم دیا تھا. نام سے جانا جاتا وسائل سے متعلق اثاثوں کا کوئی تعلق نیشنل احتساب بیورو (نیب) 
میں یا تو اس کے خلاف درج نہیں کیا گیا تھا

دوسری جانب، ایس سی نے سابق وزیر اعظم نواز شریف کے
 خلاف جیو کو حکم دیا تھا کہ 1986 میں واپس پپپتان ضلع میں ایک اققف کی زمین پر مبینہ طور پر اقوام متحدہ کی زمین مختص کرنے کے لئے جب وہ پنجاب کے وزیر اعلی تھے. نواز نواز سے باہر منتقل، مریم نواز نواز کو بھی میفائر کے اپارٹمنٹس کے سلسلے میں ایک جیوٹ کے سامنے اپنی معصومیت ثابت کرنے کے لئے بھی کہا گیا تھا. اسی طرح، سعد رفیق اور شہباز شریف دونوں کو ان کے اقتدار کو غلط استعمال کرنے اور بدعنوانی کے طریقوں میں ان کے مبینہ ملوث ہونے کے لئے قیدیوں کا سامنا کرنا پڑا ہے. تاہم، خانم کا کیس ایک استثناء ہے. وہ عدالت میں آئی، اس نے ایک سادہ وضاحت کی پیشکش کی، اس نے کہا کہ اس نے اپنی خود مختار دارالحکومت کے ساتھ دوبئی میں جائیداد خریدا اور نصف قرضہ سے لے کر نصف نصیحت کی تھی - اور ان کی توثیق کو بغیر کسی انکوائری کے بغیر لازمی طور پر سمجھا جاتا ہے.

سوال یہ سوال کرتا ہے: کیا ملک میں موجود ایک انصافی اور عدلیہ کی دوہری معیار ہے؟ سب کے بعد، اگر سابق وزیراعظم، اس کے بھائی، بیٹی اور دیگر پارٹی کے اراکین اثاثوں سے متعلق انکوائریوں کا سامنا کرسکتے ہیں کہ وہ ظاہر کرنے میں ناکام رہے، تو ہمیں حیرت ہے کہ خانمم کو اس عمل کے تابع کیوں نہیں ہونا چاہئے. سب کے بعد، اگر وہ اس کے معصومیت کے ایک جیوٹ کے سامنے ثابت کرتی ہے، تو وہ آسانی سے صاف چٹان حاصل کرسکتی ہے اور اس کی بہترین مثال قائم کرے گی کہ نایا پاکستان احتساب واقعی واقعی بورڈ میں ہے، اور نہ صرف ایک اور ڈرائیو کا ڈینٹ پارٹیوں کا مطلب ہے. اپوزیشن خانم کو پہلے ہی اعتراف کیا گیا تھا کہ انہوں نے اپنی جائیداد ظاہر نہیں کی، برج خلیفہ کے قریب واقع مہنگی علاقوں میں سے ایک میں واقع ایک عیش و آرام کی فلیٹ، وفاقی بورڈ آف ریونیو (ایف بی آر) میں. ایف بی آر کی اپنی رپورٹ نے خانم کو بیان کیا کہ اس کے خلاف جاری کردہ نوٹسوں کو غیرمعمولی اور غیر ذمہ دار قرار دیا جائے. اور ابھی تک وہ آسان نہیں چلے جاتے ہیں، غیر قانونی اثاثوں کے باوجود وہ صرف ایک ہی جرم کی سزا دینے کے لۓ ٹھیک ہے. اگر خانم کو آزاد ہونے کی اجازت ہے، تو کھیل میں ہر ایک کے لئے اصول کیوں مختلف ہیں؟ مریم کا جرمانہ ادا کرنے کی بجائے سات برس کیوں کی گئی تھی؟ اس طرح، خانمم کو صرف ایک ہی سنجیدگی سے چارج کرنے کا فیصلہ ہمارے اداروں کی اعتبار سے نفرت کرتا ہے اور صرف حزب اختلاف کی داستان اور اخلاقیات کا محتاج مضبوط ہوتا ہے جو احتسابی حملے کے دعوی کا دعوی کرتا ہے وہ دیگر سیاسی جماعتوں کو کمزور کرنے کا مطلب ہے.

خانمم کے کیس میں کھیلنے میں ایک اور زاویہ موجود ہے. خانوم اسی آدمی کی بہن ہے جو بدعنوان کے بارے میں بات چیت کرتے ہوئے پاکستان کو برباد کرنے کے بارے میں بات کرتی ہے اور جو اس نے تمام لوگوں کو قید کیا ہے جو ملک لوٹ چکے ہیں اور غیر ملکی اثاثوں میں غیر ملکی ملکیت رکھتے ہیں. کم از کم. ہم نے پہلے ہی دیکھا ہے کہ عمران کسی بھی غیر جانبدار اور غیر جانبدار احتساب میں دلچسپی نہیں رکھتے. وہ صرف کسی بھی قسم کی بدعنوان کا نعرہ استعمال کررہا ہے کہ ان کی حمایت کی بنیاد اور ناقدین اپنی حکومت کی ناپسندیدہ کارکردگی سے پریشان ہوں. بالآخر، عمران نے گزشتہ پانچ سالوں کے اخلاقی سطح پر اخلاقیات اور اخلاقیات کے بارے میں بات نہیں کی ہے، پھر اب وہ خاموش کیوں ہے؟ آج تک، عمران نے اپنی بہن کے غیر منقولہ اثاثے پر تبصرہ نہیں کیا، لیکن وہ کسی بھی مشق میں شامل ہونے والی سلاخوں کے پیچھے ڈالنے میں دھمکی دیتے رہیں. شاید احتساب کی وجہ سے عمران عمران کا مطلب یہ ہے کہ انکے جواب دہندگان یا اس کے سیاسی مخالفین ہیں؟ نواز شریف نے اسی وجہ سے تخین کو غیر قانونی قرار دیا ہے، اس کے باوجود جہانگیر تیین پارٹی کے معاملات اور پنجاب صوبے کو چلانے کے لئے اجازت دی ہے. اور پھر حقیقت یہ ہے کہ الیم خان اور ذوالفقار بخاری کی طرح نیبوں کے محکموں سے لطف اندوز ہیں، نیب کی تحقیقات کے باوجود. کیوں کہ وہ عدالتوں سے مطالبہ کرتے ہیں کہ وہ عدالتوں سے پوچھیں کہ خانوم کے مقدمے میں انہوں نے شریف، آصف علی زرداری، اور باقی مسلم لیگ (ن) کے مسلم لیگ (ن) کے لئے کیا طریقہ پیش کیا؟ خاموش رہتا ہے کہ وہ صرف اس کے مخالفین کو مظلوم کرنے کے لۓ احتساب کی نعرہ کا استعمال کر رہا ہے. جہاں تک احتساب اور بدعنوانی کا تعلق ہے، ہم نے ایوب خان کے دور سے اس کو دیکھ لیا ہے، اور اب تک تاریخ کے عدالت میں بدعنوان کا کوئی بڑا سیاسی رہنما ثابت نہیں کیا گیا ہے. عمران بات کر سکتے ہیں، لیکن اس بار بار اس نے اپنے رویے سے واضح کیا ہے کہ وہ بات چلنے میں دلچسپی نہیں رکھتے. قانون اس طرح کے وسیع ڈبل معیار کے ساتھ اسی معاملات کے ساتھ افراد کا علاج کر رہا ہے کیوں نہیں کے لئے کوئی عقلی جائزے نہیں ہے. خانم کا مقدمہ ایک یاد دہانی ہے کہ پاکستان ابھی تک ماضی کی غلطیوں سے سیکھنے کے لئے تیار نہیں ہے، اور اس جمہوریت میں سیاسی اختلافات کو سزا دی جانی چاہئے.

ایک بار مارٹن لوٹر کنگ نے کہا،
 "جسٹس ہر جگہ انصاف کو کم سے کم سے محروم کرتا ہے".

پاکستان میں، انصاف پسندوں کو ذاتی پسند اور ناخوشگوار کی بنیاد پر تقسیم کیا جا رہا ہے، لہذا دو لوگوں کو اسی جرم کے لۓ مختلف طریقے سے ادائیگی کی جاتی ہے. یہ ہمارے مستقبل کے لئے ایک اچھا اشارہ نہیں ہے. اپوزیشن نے خانہ کو اپنے اثاثوں کو اپنے بھائی کے پیسہ اور اثر و رسوخ کے ذریعہ پر الزام لگایا ہے کہ اس کا نام دبئی لیک میں آیا تھا. اسی طرح مثال کے طور پر پاناما کے کاغذات کے بعد ہوا، جہاں نواز براہ راست نامزد نہیں کیا گیا تھا، لیکن وہ اپنے بچوں کے نام کے تحت امت کو جمع کرنے پر شبہ گزار رہا تھا اور انہیں غیر قانونی قرار دیا گیا تھا اور انہیں نیب کو اس ثبوت کے ساتھ مطمئن نہیں کرنے کے لئے قید کیا گیا تھا. عدالتوں اور نیب نے حال ہی میں مقرر کردہ مطابق، خانم کو بھی جیو ٹی کے ذریعہ اچھی طرح سے تحقیق کی ضرورت ہے. اگر نواز اور زرداری جیسے لوگوں کے لئے کسی کو حکم دیا جاسکتا ہے تو پھر خانم کیوں نہیں؟ پاکستان میں کوئی انفرادی یا ادارے خود کو ذمہ دارانہ طور پر برقرار رکھنے کے لئے تیار نہیں لگتا ہے، اور پھر بھی ہر ایک کو متضاد اور سیاسی حریفوں کو احتساب کرنے کا عزم ہے. ایسا لگتا ہے جیسے ہم حلقوں میں چل رہے ہیں، جیسا کہ 'احتساب' لوگوں کو بھوک اور منفی سیاسی اور سماجی آرڈر میں یرغمل رکھنے کے لئے ایک بزنس بن گیا ہے. آگے بڑھنے کا واحد راستہ سچائی اور مصالحت کمیشن کا قیام ہے جہاں ہر سیاستدان اور ادارہ جوابدہ ہونا چاہئے؛ دوسری صورت میں ہم اس حلقے سے باہر کبھی نہیں نکلیں گے. احتساب گھر پر شروع ہوتا ہے، اور عمران نے شیخ کو پبلک اکاؤنٹس کمیشن کی صدارت کو صحیح سمت میں ایک قدم قرار دیا. لیکن خانم کے معاملے پر فیصلہ ایک اور قدم ہے، اور حکومت کو ثابت کرنے کے لۓ اقدامات کئے جائیں گے کہ وزیراعظم کی بہن کو اپنے جرم کے لئے بھی بچایا جائے گا.